| 24-25 | |  Albin Boija (G) | 2003 | Sundsvall, SWE | - |
| 23-24 | |  Will Smith (F) | 2005 | Lexington, MA, USA | San Jose Sharks (2023) |
| 22-23 | | Lane Hutson (D) | 2004 | North Barrington, IL, USA | Montréal Canadiens (2022) |
| 21-22 | | Bobby Trivigno (F) | 1999 | Setauket, NY, USA | - |
| 20-21 | | Bobby Trivigno (F) | 1999 | Setauket, NY, USA | - |
| 18-19 | | Cayden Primeau (G) | 1999 | Farmington Hills, MI, USA | Montréal Canadiens (2017) |
| 17-18 | | Jake Oettinger (G) | 1998 | Lakeville, MN, USA | Dallas Stars (2017) |
| 16-17 | | C.J. Smith (F) | 1994 | Des Moines, IA, USA | - |
| 15-16 | | Kevin Boyle (G) | 1992 | Manalapan, NJ, USA | - |
| 14-15 | | Jack Eichel (F) | 1996 | North Chelmsford, MA, USA | Buffalo Sabres (2015) |
| 13-14 | | Connor Hellebuyck (G) | 1993 | Commerce, MI, USA | Winnipeg Jets (2012) |
| 12-13 | | Connor Hellebuyck (G) | 1993 | Commerce, MI, USA | Winnipeg Jets (2012) |
| 11-12 | | Johnny Gaudreau (F) | 1993 | Salem, NJ, USA | Calgary Flames (2011) |
| 10-11 | | Cam Atkinson (F) | 1989 | Greenwich, CT, USA | Columbus Blue Jackets (2008) |
| 09-10 | | Matt Lombardi (F) | 1987 | Milton, MA, USA | - |
| 08-09 | |  Kieran Millan (G) | 1989 | Edmonton, AB, CAN | Colorado Avalanche (2009) |
| 07-08 | | Nathan Gerbe (F) | 1987 | Oxford, MI, USA | Buffalo Sabres (2005) |
| 06-07 | | Brock Bradford (F) | 1987 | Burnaby, BC, CAN | Boston Bruins (2005) |
| 05-06 | | David Van Der Gulik (F) | 1983 | Abbotsford, BC, CAN | Calgary Flames (2002) |
| 04-05 | | Brian Boyle (F) | 1984 | Hingham, MA, USA | Los Angeles Kings (2003) |
| 03-04 | | Jimmy Howard (G) | 1984 | Ogdensburg, NY, USA | Detroit Red Wings (2003) |
| 02-03 | | Sean Fields (G) | 1981 | Edmonton, AB, CAN | - |
| 01-02 | | Darren Haydar (F) | 1979 | Milton, ON, CAN | Nashville Predators (1999) |
| 00-01 | | Chuck Kobasew (F) | 1982 | Osoyoos, BC, CAN | Calgary Flames (2001) |
| 99-00 | | Niko Dimitrakos (F) | 1979 | Boston, MA, USA | San Jose Sharks (1999) |
| 98-99 | | Blake Bellefeuille (F) | 1977 | Framingham, MA, USA | - |
| 97-98 | | Marty Reasoner (F) | 1977 | Honeoye Falls, NY, USA | St. Louis Blues (1996) |
| 96-97 | | Michel Larocque (G) | 1976 | Lahr, GER | San Jose Sharks (1996) |
| 95-96 | | Joe Hulbig (F) | 1973 | Norwood, MA, USA | Edmonton Oilers (1992) |
| 94-95 | | Robert Bell (G) | 1971 | Vancouver, BC, CAN | - |
| 93-94 | | Dwayne Roloson (G) | 1969 | Simcoe, ON, CAN | - |
| 92-93 | | Jim Montgomery (F) | 1969 | Montréal, QC, CAN | - |
| 91-92 | | Scott Pellerin (F) | 1970 | Shediac, NB, CAN | New Jersey Devils (1989) |
| 90-91 | | Shawn McEachern (F) | 1969 | Waltham, MA, USA | Pittsburgh Penguins (1987) |
| 89-90 | | Scott LaGrand (G) | 1970 | Potsdam, NY, USA | Philadelphia Flyers (1988) |
| 88-89 | | Bob Beers (D) | 1967 | Pittsburgh, PA, USA | Boston Bruins (1985) |
| 87-88 | | Bruce Racine (G) | 1966 | Cornwall, ON, CAN | Pittsburgh Penguins (1985) |
| 86-87 | | Brian Leetch (D) | 1968 | Corpus Christi, TX, USA | New York Rangers (1986) |
| 85-86 | | Peter Marshall (F) | 1963 | Beverly, MA, USA | - |
| 84-85 | | Chris Terreri (G) | 1964 | Providence, RI, USA | New Jersey Devils (1983) |
