| 24-25 | |  Alexander Tracy (G) | 2001 | Chicago, IL, USA | - |
| 23-24 | | Mattias Sholl (G) | 2000 | Hermosa Beach, CA, USA | - |
| 22-23 | | Blake Pietila (G) | 2000 | Howell, MI, USA | - |
| 21-22 | | Dryden McKay (G) | 1997 | Downers Grove, IL, USA | - |
| 12-13 | | Brady Hjelle (G) | 1990 | International Falls, MN, USA | - |
| 11-12 | | Connor Knapp (G) | 1990 | York, NY, USA | Buffalo Sabres (2009) |
| 10-11 | | Shawn Hunwick (G) | 1987 | Sterling Heights, MI, USA | - |
| 09-10 | | Cody Reichard (G) | 1987 | Celina, OH, USA | - |
| 08-09 | |  Chad Johnson (G) | 1986 | Saskatoon, SK, CAN | Pittsburgh Penguins (2006) |
| 07-08 | | Jeff Zatkoff (G) | 1987 | Detroit, MI, USA | Los Angeles Kings (2006) |
| 06-07 | | David Brown (G) | 1985 | Stoney Creek, ON, CAN | Pittsburgh Penguins (2004) |
| 05-06 | | Charlie Effinger (G) | 1985 | Belleville, IL, USA | - |
| 04-05 | |  Tuomas Tarkki (G) | 1980 | Rauma, FIN | - |
| 03-04 | | Dominic Vicari (G) | 1984 | Clinton Township, MI, USA | - |
| 02-03 | | Mike Betz (G) | 1981 | Elizabeth, PA, USA | - |
| 01-02 | | Ryan Miller (G) | 1980 | East Lansing, MI, USA | Buffalo Sabres (1999) |
| 00-01 | | Ryan Miller (G) | 1980 | East Lansing, MI, USA | Buffalo Sabres (1999) |
| 99-00 | | Ryan Miller (G) | 1980 | East Lansing, MI, USA | Buffalo Sabres (1999) |
| 96-97 | | Marty Turco (G) | 1975 | Sault Ste. Marie, ON, CAN | Dallas Stars (1994) |
| 95-96 | | Marc Magliarditi (G) | 1976 | Niagara Falls, NY, USA | Chicago Blackhawks (1995) |
| 94-95 | | Chuck Thuss (G) | 1972 | Arkona, ON, CAN | - |
| 92-93 | | Steve Shields (G) | 1972 | Toronto, ON, CAN | Buffalo Sabres (1991) |