| 23-24 | |  Brent Beswick (F) | 2006 | Wyckoff, NJ, USA | - |
| 22-23 | | Jason Cai (G) | 2005 | Basking Ridge, NJ, USA | - |
| 21-22 | | Zachary Wagnon (F) | 2004 | Red Bank, NJ, USA | - |
| 19-20 | | Jake Donohoe (G) | 2003 | Coopersburg, PA, USA | - |
| 18-19 | | Tyler Sedlak (F) | 2000 | Wyckoff, NJ, USA | - |
| 17-18 | | Mickey Burns (F) | 2000 | Wayne, NJ, USA | - |
| 16-17 | | Troy Kobryn (G) | 1999 | Hillsborough, NJ, USA | - |
| 15-16 | | Andrew Petrillo (D) | 1998 | Pompton Plains, NJ, USA | - |
| 14-15 | | Ryan Bogan (D) | 1998 | Brick, NJ, USA | - |
| 13-14 | | Alex Whelan (F) | 1997 | Ramsey, NJ, USA | - |
| 12-13 | | John Baiocco (F) | 1995 | Harding, NJ, USA | - |
| 11-12 | | Tommy Muratore (D) | 1994 | Mendham, NJ, USA | - |
| 10-11 | | Dan Fullam (G) | 1992 | Randolph, NJ, USA | - |
| 09-10 | | Kenny Agostino (F) | 1992 | Morristown, NJ, USA | Pittsburgh Penguins (2010) |
| 08-09 | | Kenny Agostino (F) | 1992 | Morristown, NJ, USA | Pittsburgh Penguins (2010) |
| 07-08 | | Charles Nerbak (F) | 1990 | Martinsville, NJ, USA | - |
| 06-07 | | Kevin Healey (G) | - | Woodbury, NJ, USA | - |
| 05-06 | | Mike Cacciotti (F) | 1988 | Staten Island, NY, USA | - |
| 02-03 | | Anthony Randazzo (F) | 1985 | NJ, USA | - |
| 01-02 | | Kevin Kielt (D) | 1984 | Brick, NJ, USA | - |
| 00-01 | | Matt Radoslovich (F) | 1983 | Wanaque, NJ, USA | - |
| 98-99 | | Brandon Doria (F) | 1981 | Bayonne, NJ, USA | - |
| 96-97 | | Harry Schwefel (F) | 1979 | Toms River, NJ, USA | - |
| 94-95 | |  Mats Carseberg (F) | - | | - |
| 93-94 | | Greg Toskos (F) | 1975 | Waldwick, NJ, USA | - |
| 92-93 | | Paul Giblin (F) | 1976 | Paramus, NJ, USA | - |
